So did Jordan Esparza-Kelley, a spokesperson for the Chicago branch of the Council on American-Islamic Relations. A former CLC student, Esparza-Kelley also said Abernathy should apologize for “spreading this harmful rhetoric.”
“Many young Muslim students in the Lake County area already attend predominantly white institutions where they face bullying and harassment because of their faith,” he said. “To see their religion be made a mockery by a school trustee only resurfaces a sense of being othered.”
By : By Russell Lissau | rlissau@dailyherald.com
A suburban Republican Party leader and school board member is being chastised for a social media post questioning Muslims’ fitness to hold elected office.
Lake County GOP Chair and College of Lake County Trustee Dawn Abernathy on Monday posted to Facebook an image of a rainbow Pride flag with overlaid text about a “Muslim-Majority City” that banned such flags and a judicial ruling supporting the prohibition.
The text referred to Hamtramck, Michigan, which in 2023 banned displaying Pride flags on city property. That ban — which also applies to flags promoting religious, ethnic, racial or political groups — was upheld by a federal appellate court this summer.
Hamtramck has a large Muslim population and all the city council members at the time were Muslim.
Abernathy, an outspoken supporter of LGBTQ rights, concluded her caption for the image by writing, in all capital letters, “NOW DO YOU SEE WHAT IS WRONG WITH ELECTING MUSLIMS!” She later deleted that line.
State Sen.-elect Nabeela Syed, an Inverness Democrat who now serves in the state House and is Muslim, called Abernathy’s post “hateful and bigoted.”
“It draws into question how she is supposed to represent students of all faiths and backgrounds when she holds these deeply hateful views,” Syed said. “To say that a person should not hold elected office because of their identity or faith is unacceptable.”
Abernathy’s post also drew a strong rebuke from state Rep. Daniel Didech, chair of the Lake County Democratic organization. Citing the clause in the U.S. Constitution that explicitly bans religious tests for officeholders, Didech noted that whether Muslims or members of any religious group should hold elected office “is not up for debate in this country.”
“Dawn Abernathy would fail a middle school Constitution test,” said Didech, of Buffalo Grove. “Her comments are not just offensive and racist, but they are deeply un-American.”
Didech called for Abernathy to resign from the CLC board.
So did Jordan Esparza-Kelley, a spokesperson for the Chicago branch of the Council on American-Islamic Relations. A former CLC student, Esparza-Kelley also said Abernathy should apologize for “spreading this harmful rhetoric.”
“Many young Muslim students in the Lake County area already attend predominantly white institutions where they face bullying and harassment because of their faith,” he said. “To see their religion be made a mockery by a school trustee only resurfaces a sense of being othered.”
Lindsey Nemcek, CLC’s interim public relations and marketing director, noted that Abernathy’s comments on her Facebook page don’t represent the College of Lake County or its board. Regardless, the college respects Abernathy’s constitutional free speech protections, “even when it does not share the views expressed,” Nemcek said.
“The College of Lake County will continue to focus on serving students and the community through its mission and values of excellence, purpose, integrity, compassion, unity and inclusion,” Nemcek said.
Abernathy told the Daily Herald she deleted the final line of the Facebook post because it’s not fair to blame all Muslims for policies with which she disagrees. She expressed fears, however, that electing more Muslim Americans could lead to elements of Sharia — the laws that form the Islamic tradition — being implemented here, including a crackdown on LGBTQ rights.
Attempts to reach other members of the Lake County Republican Party’s executive committee for this story were unsuccessful.
This isn’t the first time Abernathy has been criticized over a political Facebook post. While running for re-election to the Mundelein village board In 2017, she claimed Korean American mayoral hopeful Holly Kim’s slate of candidates was backed by “Korean money.” Abernathy subsequently apologized.
Hamtramck is far from the only community that’s been divided over displaying the Pride flag. In the Chicago area, similar debates have occurred in Des Plaines, Mount Prospect, Palatine and other suburbs.

